Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. When you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support the site's research and upkeep.

Scriveiner vs Hongdian Black Forest vs Pilot Metropolitan (2026): Best Metal Gift & Office Pen Under $45

Tags:comparisonScriveinerHongdian Black ForestPilot Metropolitangift fountain penmetal fountain pen
By Fountain Pen Expert Team • Published November 18, 2026

If you are buying a formal gift where luxury unboxing and a screw-on cap matter most, buy the Scriveiner Black Lacquer ($39–44). If you want the best everyday metal fountain pen for your own desk at half the price, choose the Pilot Metropolitan ($23–28) for the finest, cleanest Japanese nib on cheap office paper, or the Hongdian Black Forest 1851 ($18–22) for a rugged knurled-metal EDC pen.

Quick Buying Guide: Best Metal Office & Gift Pen Under $45

🏆 Best Pure Writer on Office Paper
Pilot Metropolitan Black Fine (91111)

Pilot Metropolitan (Brass + Japanese Fine)

Pilot Metropolitan Black Fine (91111) · Typical: $25-30

Best if: Pilot’s precision Japanese Fine nib produces crisp, smudge-free lines even on standard office copy paper.

Setup note: Uses proprietary Pilot cartridges; has a noticeable step-down from barrel to grip.

Check Pilot Metropolitan on Amazon →
💰 Best Under-$22 Metal Value
Hongdian Black Forest 1851

Hongdian Black Forest 1851

Hongdian Black Forest 1851 · Typical: $16-22

Best if: All-metal matte-black knurled barrel (~35g) with a PVD black nib and converter included under $22.

Setup note: Ships with an empty converter (no ink cartridges in the box); pair with bottled ink.

Check Hongdian Black Forest →
🎁 Best Luxury Gift Presentation
Scriveiner Luxury Fountain Pen Black Lacquer

Scriveiner Black Lacquer (Schmidt Nib)

Scriveiner Luxury Fountain Pen Black Lacquer · Typical: $45-60

Best if: Heavy brass lacquer body with threaded cap, German Schmidt Fine nib, converter, and 2 cartridges in a gift box.

Setup note: Costs ~$40; you are paying extra for the jewelry-style gift box and lacquer finish.

Check Scriveiner on Amazon →
Waterman Serenity Blue

Essential Desk Companion: Waterman Serenity Blue (50ml Bottled Ink)

All three pens include a converter for bottled ink (and the Hongdian ships without cartridges). Adding one bottle of Waterman Serenity Blue guarantees a ready-to-write setup on day one.

Head-to-Head Spec Comparison

Feature Scriveiner Black Lacquer Hongdian Black Forest 1851 Pilot Metropolitan
Typical Price $39–$44 $18–$22 $23–$28
Body Material & Weight Brass with multi-coat lacquer (~34 g) Anodized knurled brass/metal (~35 g) Matte brass barrel + resin grip (~26 g)
Cap Mechanism Threaded screw cap (posts securely via threads) Firm snap cap Firm snap cap
Nib Origin & Width German Schmidt steel nib (Western Fine) Hongdian PVD steel nib (EF, Fine, or Bent/Fude) Japanese Pilot steel nib (True Fine or Medium)
Included in Box Schmidt converter + 2 standard cartridges Converter only (No ink included) 1 Pilot cartridge + squeeze converter

Quick Comparison

ProductBest For / RolePriceKey HighlightsAction
fountain pen$25-30
  • ✓Brass barrel with black finish
  • ✓Smooth fine nib
Check Price
fountain pen$16-22
  • ✓Matte black metal body
  • ✓PVD coated stainless nib
Check Price
gift fountain pen$45-60
  • ✓Gift-box presentation
  • ✓Black lacquer styling with gold-tone trim
Check Price

How They Compare in Real Office & Gift Scenarios

1. Nib Line Width on Cheap Copy Paper

Because the Scriveiner Black Lacquer uses a German Schmidt nib, its "Fine" writes like a Western Fine (~0.5 mm)—smooth and wet, which feels luxurious on 90gsm journals but can show slight feathering on cheap 20lb office copy paper. The Pilot Metropolitan Fine uses a Japanese Fine (~0.38–0.4 mm), making it far safer for small handwriting, sticky notes, and everyday office forms.

2. Screw Cap vs Snap Cap

The Scriveiner uses a threaded cap that unscrews to open and threads onto the back of the barrel to post. That feels deliberate for signing documents or journaling, but if you cap and uncap your pen twenty times during a meeting, the snap caps on the Hongdian Black Forest and Pilot Metropolitan are much faster.

3. Gift Unboxing vs Enthusiast Value

If you are shopping for a graduation, promotion, or client gift—and the recipient has never owned a fountain pen—the Scriveiner’s pull-out drawer box with both standard international cartridges and a converter requires zero explanation. If you are shopping on a sub-$35 budget and want a complete ready-to-write gift bundle, pair the Hongdian Black Forest ($18) with a bottle of Waterman Serenity Blue ($12). (Also see Scriveiner vs Wordsworth & Black and Hongdian Black Forest vs Pilot Metropolitan.)

Frequently Asked Questions

Where are Scriveiner fountain pens actually made?

Scriveiner is a UK-based brand (designed in London) that manufactures its brass lacquer bodies in China and equips them with German-made Schmidt nibs and Schmidt converters.

Does the Scriveiner write better than the Pilot Metropolitan or Hongdian Black Forest?

The Scriveiner’s German Schmidt nib is smooth and slightly wetter than average, while the Pilot Metropolitan’s Japanese steel Fine nib writes a noticeably crisper, finer line that feathers less on cheap office copy paper. The Hongdian Black Forest offers the easiest screw-in nib replacement at half the price.

Which of the three is best as an executive or graduation gift?

Scriveiner wins on luxury gift unboxing (presentation box, spare cartridges, converter, and high-gloss lacquer + gold/chrome trim). If your budget is under $25, the Hongdian Black Forest 1851 in its metal or velvet gift box is the best value gift.

Do all three pens come with ink in the box?

The Scriveiner includes both a Schmidt converter and two standard cartridges. The Pilot Metropolitan includes one Pilot black cartridge and a squeeze converter. The Hongdian Black Forest includes a converter only (no ink cartridges in the box), so you must pair it with bottled ink or Hongdian 3.4mm cartridges.

Related Guides & Reviews

Continue comparing options and side-by-side evaluations.

All Guides →